Management decisions in nontraumatic complaints of arm, neck, and shoulder in general practice
From: Ann Fam Med. 2009 Sep-Oct;7(5):446-54
Complaints of arm, neck, and shoulder pain are very common in Western societies. In the Netherlands the estimated 12-month prevalence in the general population was 31% for neck pain, 30% for shoulder pain, 11% for elbow pain, and 18% for wrist or hand pain. Studies have reported that of the respondents with noninflammatory musculoskeletal pain, about 30% to 45% contacted their general practitioner. In Dutch general practice, incidence data for patients with nontraumatic arm, neck, or shoulder complaints show 97 consultations per 1,000 registered persons annually.
Common management options for patients with nontraumatic arm, neck, and shoulder complaints are watchful waiting, additional diagnostic tests, prescription of medication, referral for physiotherapy, a corticosteroid injection, and referral for medical specialist care. Use of these 6 management options shows wide variation, however, both between and within diagnostic groups. Until now, no studies have evaluated the determinants that contribute to variation in the management of these complaints. Part of this variation may be explained by the diagnosis, which, because of its natural course and available treatment, usually guides management. Also, patient and complaint characteristics may influence management. In the Netherlands guidelines issued by the Dutch College of General Practitioners are available for epicondylitis and shoulder complaints; in both guidelines, management advice is partly based on differences in the levels of hindrance (pain severity and functional limitations). In other study populations, patient and complaint characteristics reported to be associated with management options are distress, poor perceived health, age, and sex. Additionally, indicators of poor prognosis can play a role in management decisions. In our earlier study in this population, indicators of poor prognosis were long duration of the complaints at baseline, having musculoskeletal comorbidity, recurrent complaint, low social support, and a high somatization level.
The authors wanted to evaluate associations between diagnosis and characteristics of the patient, complaint, and general practitioner, as well as 6 common management decisions, in patients with nontraumatic arm, neck, and shoulder complaints at the time of the first consultation with their physician. They undertook an observational cohort study set in 21 Dutch general practices, including 682 patients with nontraumatic complaints of arm, neck, and shoulder. The outcome measure was application (yes/no) of a specific management option: watchful waiting, additional diagnostic tests, prescription of medication, corticosteroid injection, referral for physiotherapy, and referral for medical specialist care. Separate multilevel analyses showed that overall, the diagnostic category, having long duration of complaints, and reporting many functional limitations were most frequently associated with the choice of a management option. For watchful waiting, only complaint variables played a role (long duration of complaints, high complaint severity, many functional limitations, recurrent complaint). All these variables were negatively associated with watchful waiting. When opting for 1 of the 5 other management options, several physician characteristics played a role as well. Less clinical experience was associated with additional diagnostic tests and referral to a medical specialist. General practitioners working in a solo practice more frequently referred to a medical specialist. General practitioners working in a rural area more frequently referred for physiotherapy. Female General practitioners prescribed medication less frequently. Physicians with special interest in musculoskeletal complaints gave corticosteroid injections more frequently.
Diagnostic category, long duration of complaints, and high functional limitations were key variables in management decisions with arm, neck, and shoulder complaints complaints. In addition, several physician characteristics played a role as well.
